replace water heater

A water heater typically uses much less energy than a furnace, but it also costs less to replace, so replacing a water heater often turns out to be cost-effective.

Natural gas water heaters are now available that are as much as 74% efficient, compared to as low as 49% for old units.  Electric water heaters are 100% efficient, but electricity costs more than gas, so they are actually more expensive to operate.  Heat-pump water heaters are as much as 400% efficient and can often pay for themselves as quickly as gas, even though they cost more.  The most efficient water heaters are solar, but not all houses get enough sun exposure to make solar water heating worthwhile.

We often find gas water heaters that are not drafting properly -- that is, their exhaust flows into the house instead of out the flue pipe -- or that are producing far too much carbon monoxide.  Either of these issues by itself is not a problem, but when they are combined, there is grave danger of carbon monoxide poisoning!  The immediate solution is to have the water heater repaired; however the long-term solution is to replace it with a sealed-combustion unit, or with an electric or solar one that does not produce carbon monoxide.

Commonly when someone's gas bill is high all year 'round, it is because they are using warm or hot water in the washing machine.  Modern washing machines do not require hot water to get clothes clean.  An Efficiency Kansas loan will not cover replacing a washing machine, but doing so at your own expense will usually pay for itself within a year or two.

1977 bi-level, Emporia

We found high levels of carbon monoxide from both the water heater and furnace, plus the water heater was spilling its exhaust into the laundry room.  This was an immediate safety hazard.

The house was also found to be too airtight for two people, let alone the number who could live in its 6 bedrooms.  We recommended a ventilation system.

Average Electric bill:
$66.00
Average Gas bill:
$37.33
Predicted savings:
$65.00 per year

Improvements recommended

2009 ranch home, Emporia

This house was very recently renovated but nonetheless leaked 50% more air than necessary.  Most of the air leakage was from the whole-house fan.  There was also a very leaky return air duct that passed through an uninsulated crawl space on its way to the heat pump.

We recommended a heat pump water heater to replace both the older gas water heater and the dehumidifier in the equipment room.

Conditioned Area:
3,872 square feet
Predicted savings:
$706.00 per year

Improvements recommended

1910 ranch home, Emporia

This house was in relatively poor condition compared to what we usually see.  There were numerous significant problems, ranging from fire hazards (cumbustible insulation in the electrical boxes -- see photo) to mold hazards (rotting floor boards in the mechanical closet -- see photo), to toxic gas (water heater producing more than 63x the safe amount of carbon monoxide), to biological hazards (squirrels living in the attic).  

cellulose insulation filling uncovered electrical junction box
floor damaged from air conditioner condensate spillage
Average Electric bill:
$199.42
Average Gas bill:
$82.30
Predicted savings:
$783.00 per year

Improvements recommended

1974 Bi-Level, Emporia

This house was built very airtight -- we had to recommend adding at least 85 cubic feet per minute of heat-recovery ventilation.  Humidity had become an issue in the basement, as evidenced by a dehumidifier unable to keep up.  We recommended they consider a heat-pump water heater.

utility room ceiling open to framing
uninsulated wood box open to garage
dehumidifier unable to keep up
Conditioned Area:
3,212 square feet
Average Electric bill:
$156.63
Average Gas bill:
$49.63
Predicted savings:
$688.00 per year

Improvements recommended

1959 ranch home, Lawrence

This small, two-bedroom house was very well built -- except for the parts that weren't.  The windows in the lofted bedrooms were particularly leaky.  The water heater and furnace were all the way at one end of the house, on an exterior wall.  The plumbing and ducts ran through the unheated, vented crawl space.  In the course of our inspection we also found the dryer vent entirely clogged with lint.

Conditioned Area:
864 square feet
Predicted savings:
$445.00 per year

Improvements recommended

1912 Old Style house, Emporia

The owners of this house had only recently moved in, after renting it to others.  The tenants had used the thermostat very frugally so that the heating bills were unusually low and the computer model could not be made to match accurately.

We found a gas leak at the end of an old disconnected pipe where an appliance had been.  We recommended removing and recycling the pipe, capping off the junction.

leaking water heater
wet crack in basement wall
Conditioned Area:
2,167 square feet
Average Electric bill:
$93.90
Average Gas bill:
$111.37
Predicted savings:
$1,407.00 per year

Improvements recommended

1968 ranch home, Emporia

This house had extremely high baseline electricity consumption.  Our main recommendation to the homeowners was that they reconsider whether they need to run two full-size freezers, three refrigerators, and a hot tub year-round.

disconnected downspout
missing insulation in garage ceiling
disconnected downspout
disconnected bathroom ventilator
deteriorated pressboard paneling in laundry room
Conditioned Area:
3,697 square feet
Average Electric bill:
$216.02
Average Gas bill:
$81.99
Predicted savings:
$641.00 per year

Improvements recommended

1910 ranch home, Lebo

This manufactured house had two wall furnaces, one of which had been replaced just months before we arrived.  Since these wall furnaces are natural draft appliances (using the air from the room to draw exhaust up the flue pipe), whenever they are not in use their flue pipes leak air from the outdoors.  We recommended replacing the older of the two furnaces and one of the window air conditioners with a mini-split heat pump so that the flue pipe could be permanently sealed.

We recommended a tankless water heater since the house had only one bathroom and one resident.

Conditioned Area:
1,762 square feet
Average Electric bill:
$105.24
Predicted savings:
$1,195.00 per year

Improvements recommended

1997 conventional, Council Grove

This house was unoccupied for most of the year, so its utility bills were extremely low, eliminating the cost-effectiveness of any efficiency improvements.  We were able to make recommendations for improvements, but our calculations of cost effectiveness were thrown off by the low bills.

gap in insulation by wiring, improvised insulation between kneewall attic space and uninsulated attic
Conditioned Area:
4,745 square feet
Average Electric bill:
$80.20
Predicted savings:
$99.00 per year

Improvements recommended

1997 conventional, Emporia

On the day we audited this house, the air conditioner was being serviced after being out of commission for several days.  The family (including three children and an elderly grandmother) had sought refuge from the summer heat by sleeping in the partly-finished basement.  Both the water heater and furnace (in the unfinished part of the basement) produced unsafe levels of carbon monoxide during our tests.  Fortunately the exhaust vented out the flue pipes correctly, so tragedy was averted!

air intake & exhaust vents
high & low ends of intake & exhaust pipes
Conditioned Area:
3,655 square feet
Average Electric bill:
$111.36
Average Gas bill:
$75.19
Predicted savings:
$488.00 per year

Improvements recommended

Pages

Subscribe to RSS - replace water heater